diff --git a/addons/shopro/controller/zy/Circle.php b/addons/shopro/controller/zy/Circle.php
index 830407b..fe09349 100644
--- a/addons/shopro/controller/zy/Circle.php
+++ b/addons/shopro/controller/zy/Circle.php
@@ -22,17 +22,17 @@ class Circle extends Base
 
         $sub = CircleModel::alias('c')
             ->join([Likes::$tableName => 'l'], 'c.id = l.circle_id', 'LEFT')
-            ->field("c.*,JSON_ARRAYAGG(JSON_OBJECT(
+            ->field("c.*,CONCAT('[',GROUP_CONCAT(JSON_OBJECT(
                 'id', l.id,
                 'user_id', l.user_id,
                 'nickname', l.nickname,
                 'avatar', l.avatar,
                 'gender', l.gender
-            )) AS likes")->group('c.id')->buildSql();
+            )), ']') AS likes")->group('c.id')->buildSql();
         $query = Comment::alias('m')
             ->join([$sub => 'c'], 'c.id = m.circle_id', 'RIGHT')
             ->field("c.*,
-             JSON_ARRAYAGG(JSON_OBJECT(
+             CONCAT('[',GROUP_CONCAT(JSON_OBJECT(
                 'id', m.id,
                 'pid', m.pid,
                 'puser_id', m.puser_id,
@@ -43,7 +43,7 @@ class Circle extends Base
                 'gender', m.gender,
                 'content', m.content,
                 'create_time', m.create_time
-            )) AS comment")->group('c.id');
+            )), ']') AS comment")->group('c.id');
         if (isset($params['club_id'])) {
             $query->where('c.club_id', $params['club_id']);
         }